6 La Mesa Police Officers Exonerated in Fatal Shooting of Andrew Yacko

Drunken husband was threatening police with shotgun in middle of Pine Street north of The Village.

Updated at 5:27 p.m. April 27, 2012

Six La Mesa police officers who opened fire on a drunken Andrew Yacko last August, killing him in the middle of Pine Street, have been exonerated after a District Attorney’s Office investigation.

Bonnie Dumanis, the district attorney running for San Diego mayor, signed a letter to La Mesa Police Chief Ed Aceves that noted Yacko threatened officers with a Winchester 12-gauge pump shotgun.

And an autopsy revealed that Yacko, 35, who died from multiple gunshot wounds, had a blood-alcohol level of 0.19 percent.  For drivers, a level of 0.08 percent is considered legally drunk.

“Based on these circumstances, it is readily apparent that Officers Tim Purdy, Scott Hildebrand, Scott Dreyer, Marcus Patrick, Rudolfo Salazar and Scott Wulfing all fired in self-defense as well as in defense of one another,” Dumanis said in a letter dated April 17 (attached). “They therefore bear no criminal liability for their actions.”

The Dumanis letter also revealed that on April 30, 2011—3 1/2 months before Yacko’s death, sheriff's deputies responded to a report of an assault with a deadly weapon in a Jamul parking lot.

“The deputies eventually learned Mr. Yacko had been involved in an argument with his wife and threatened to commit suicide,” the letter said. “At one point, Mr. Yacko had fired several shots from a shotgun and a pistol into his own truck.”

Yacko was arrested and admitted firing his guns at his truck, Dumanis said.

“He said he was upset because his wife was seeing someone else,” she said in the letter. “Deputies seized the shotgun and pistol as evidence and later conducted a search of Mr. Yacko’s home. They found a number of other guns that they impounded for safekeeping purposes.”

Yacko underwent a 72-hour psychiatric evaluation at a county facility and later was booked into county jail for discharging a firearm in a grossly negligent manner and shooting at an unoccupied vehicle.

On May 17, Yacko pleaded guilty in the Jamul case, and on July 12, he was sentenced to three years of probation and 110 days in county jail with credit for 110 days served. A 365-day jail term was stayed.

Yacko was released from jail later that night.

At 11:18 on a Friday night in mid-August, neighbors called 911 after hearing a woman screaming and seeing Yacko “armed with and pointing a gun as he walked in the street,” Dumanis wrote.

One neighbor told police: “He has his gun in his hand. He’s pointing it.... He’s yelling at the people next door .... He just got out of prison.”

Another neighbor reported, “He’s coming to my door. I can see the gun.”

All six officers told DA investigators that they saw Yacko rack the shotgun (a step before firing), the letter said.

Several of the officers repeatedly ordered Yacko to drop the gun, but he refused and racked, raised and pointed the shotgun at the officers.

“The officers all stated they opened fire because they thought Mr. Yacko was going to fire the shotgun at them or their fellow officers,” Dumanis said.

All six officers fired their weapons, which included Glock .40-caliber semi-automatic pistols and .223-caliber rifles.

“Mr. Yacko was struck by the gunfire and died at the scene,” she wrote.

The first public notice that Dumanis had made her decision was Friday on her Officer-Involved Shooting page.

“I had my web people post today,” said Steve Walker, communications director for the District Attorney’s Office.

Four days after Yacko died, a Facebook memorial page was created, listing a Chase Bank account for funeral donations.

“Andrew's life was taken from us way too soon,” said the Facebook description. “We are deeply shocked and saddened by this unfortunate event. He has left behind a wife and five children, which includes a very young son and daughter.”

Bill Jaynes April 28, 2012 at 03:05 AM
While I can't help but feel sorrow for Andrew and his family, I'm glad our cops were cleared. I caught the tail end of the incident walking to work that morning and it never occurred to me there was any question about the propriety of their actions. There was a lot of good natured joking here on Patch about the new emergency response vehicle, but it probably would have been useful to have in service that day.
Saul Rubinowitz April 28, 2012 at 03:29 PM
I agree Bill. Nothing says "Propriety of their actions" more than 19 shots at single stationary person in the middle of a city street!
Thughunter April 28, 2012 at 10:10 PM
While the death of Mr. Yacko is indeed unfortunate, I am pleased our officers were there protecting La Mesans and aren't on the hot seat for doing so. Too often, trajedy occurs and law enforcement are there afterwards to take a report. On this occasion, officers were there performing their sworn duty. While the middle of the street isn't the optimal place to discharge weapons, officers don't often have the luxury of choosing where things like this happen. I'm sure all officers were mindful about their surroundings when firing their weapons. They are trained to be. The threat of death when a shotgun is raised and pointed at you is not dependent on your location. The officers did the right thing based on the circumstances.
Bill Jaynes April 28, 2012 at 10:32 PM
I know the type of incident you're talking about, Saul, but this really isn't one of them. The stationary person was pointing a shotgun at the cops, and 19 bullets across 6 officers doesn't strike me as outrageous. You really should take a look at Pine St./Ct. to get a better feel for how dangerous the situation was. As to the response vehicle, I really just meant that it might have prevented a shooting if the officers had a little safety edge.
Deena While April 29, 2012 at 12:23 AM
Well said Thughunter. Our LMPD did a great job. I'm sorry it happened, and I'm sorry our officers had to do it, but I'm glad they were exonerated for doing their jobs. My prayers to his family and all his friends.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »