Unrelenting Ruth: Leiderman of Murray Manor is Longest-Serving Teacher
But kindergarten veteran is parting in sorrow and protest in 2012, amid 30-to-1 class sizes.
Even after all these years, Ruth Leiderman still gets nervous and can’t sleep the night before the first day of school in September. It’s the joy of being around children that keeps her going, the very thing that sparked her interest in teaching when she was a teen-age baby-sitter in Pasadena.
“I wrote my vocational notebook in seventh grade on being a teacher,” she says.
But much has changed since 1973 when Leiderman, fresh out of San Diego State, began teaching.
The war in Vietnam was nearing an end, Richard Nixon was still president and gas prices had climbed to about 40 cents a gallon. Americans had no cell phones, home computers or microwaves in the kitchen.
And—get this—kindergartners had nap time.
Leiderman, who just turned 60, can’t believe how the curriculum for kinders has evolved.
Now, she says, kindergarten is basically “like first grade” was in the 1970s.
“When I first started teaching, the kindergartners didn’t even hold a pencil,” says Leiderman, who teaches kindergarten at Murray Manor Elementary School. “It was basically developmental. It was naps, painting, all the developmental types of things. Lots of artwork, lots of cutting and pasting.”
Now, the 4-, 5- and 6-year-olds who begin school are asked to do much more. They learn to read and write. They do math. They go a full day—no more half-day classes. And nap times are history, just like 40-cents-a-gallon gasoline.
“If you would have asked me 30 years ago if kindergartners would be capable of doing that, I would have said no,” says Leiderman. “But here I am today, teaching what I thought was a first-grade program 30 years ago.”
Leiderman appreciates some of the changes, disagrees with others but remains enthusiastic about her career, which will come to an end after next school year when she plans to retire. Thirty-eight years after her first day on the job, Leiderman now ranks as the No. 1 teacher in the La Mesa-Spring Valley School District for longevity, a fact she finds hard to believe.
Especially, she says, when she feels like “I have so much energy.”
“The kids keep me young,” she says.
Long, Varied Career Since SDSU Graduation
Leiderman, who commutes each day from Poway where she lives with her husband, has taught kindergarten at Murray Manor in north La Mesa for 14 years.
Since joining the district out of SDSU, where she earned her degree in elementary education, she’s taught every grade through sixth, including a combined third-through-sixth class of gifted students at Northmont Elementary that she calls “the most magnificent experience” of her career. Being able to watch those students develop, over several years, was enormously satisfying, she says.
“They came to my wedding; they saw me through two births,” she says.
After taking about five years off after that experience to raise her two sons—now 22 and 24—Leiderman returned to teaching, and had a variety of assignments until landing at Murray Manor.
Principal Guido Magliato says Leiderman “has touched the lives of thousands of students and their families over the years,” and admires her commitment and skill.
“I love that she remains a strong advocate for all her students,” he says. “She believes passionately that we not only teach the academics but also develop the whole child developmentally.
“The mentality that has crept into some educational institutions has been ‘put away the clay.’ Not Mrs. Leiderman and her incredible kinder colleagues. I can walk into her classroom on any given day throughout the year and she has something amazing going on for the students. It could be a life-size igloo made of milk cartons, a Polar Express train running down the middle of her room, or all the students dressed as kings and queens.”
Those are examples of the old-school kindergarten values that Leiderman still believes in.
While teachers are now held more accountable for test scores and measured student growth, Leiderman continues to incorporate as much hands-on play as possible.
In her classroom, she still has sand tables, easels, a playhouse and uses clay and Play-Doh, whenever she can mold them into the curriculum.
As she says, “I’ve adapted.”
Yet she disagrees with some of the change.
“The standards have increased,” she says, explaining kindergarten evolution. “And I don’t mind saying, I personally don’t feel for the better. ... I’m actually sad to see the way it went. Very sad.
“I still think the kindergartners should be doing things other than reading and writing. There’s plenty for them to do that’s developmental. … I think learning through play is lost. I truly believe that children learn through play. And that’s gone. All those discoveries that they used to make on their own.”
Leiderman says she’s grateful that at Murray Manor she’s been allowed to blend the old with the new. She knows it’s not the norm at some schools.
As the day unfolds, two hours of language arts are scheduled in the morning, followed by recess, math, lunch and then social studies, science, music, art and “developmental time” when she can blend in the clay and the play.
And is the old-school approach hurting the new-age expectations?
No, says Magliato. He says Leiderman still “maintains rigorous academics” and her class is exceeding the reading-level expectations for this year.
“Married to My job”—Even on Vacation
Leiderman usually arrives each morning about 6:30 or 7 for the school day that begins at 8:30. Four days a week, class gets out at 2:50 p.m. (with a shorter day on Tuesday). Still, she often doesn’t leave school till about 5, cleaning up and doing prep work for the next day. Even when she gets home, she’ll often do lesson planning at night.
Teaching, she says, is her passion and she says feels “married to my job.” Even when she goes on vacation, she likes to pick up things “for the kids.”
While she’s taught many grades, kindergarten brings its own special rewards. For one thing, a teacher can watch the students for several years as they develop in later grades.
And kindergartners, she says, have an innocence that is endearing. The boys and girls have special nurturing needs that older students don’t. Sometimes, they’ll lose a tooth in class. And, when they fall down, they need a Band-Aid to make things better, even if there’s no cut.
Also, because they are such a blank slate, the impact of teaching is immediate.
“The growth from Day One till June, when we send them off to first grade, is incredible,” she says.
Retirement Coming in 2012
As much as she still loves teaching, Leiderman has decided to retire after next year.
It’s a decision, she says, that has her husband and others close to her worried. They wonder what she’s going to do without it.
“Everybody always said, the secretaries always said, ‘Oh, Ruth is going to be the one, 85 years old, walking up and down the hallways still teaching,” she says. “Because I really had no retirement date set.”
That, however, changed when fiscal shortfalls led to spending cuts, teacher layoffs and increased class sizes. For the past several years, legislation dictated that class sizes remain small—about a 20-to-1 ratio–in lower grades. Next year, however, district cuts will trim Murray Manor’s six kindergarten classes to four, and kindergarten class sizes will rise to 30.
This year, she has 21 students, and the only way she says she’s been able to cope has been because of the parents who volunteer to help each day in the room.
Thirty students, she says, is too much.
“Next year is my last year,” she says. “Do you want to know why? Write it carefully when you write it. I don’t like the way education is going. I’m upset that there’s 30 kids in kindergarten. I think there’s no business for 30 kids to be in kindergarten. And it’s become so academic it’s almost against my principles of teaching like this. Really. It shouldn’t be that way. That’s what made me make my decision.”
It’s a decision she can barely talk about without getting emotional. The idea of walking out for the last time next June is something she doesn’t want to contemplate. She has no plans. She just knows she needs to leave, yet it’s going to break her heart.
So she’s focusing on this year and next, on the teaching and the kids, saying, “I stay real positive.”
But there’s a song that’s popular right now, called The House That Built Me that she thinks of when she thinks about her career.
“The lyrics are about how when we grow up in a house, we get all our experiences from that house and from that neighborhood,” she says. “I can truly honestly say that there’s a song for me—that’s The District that Built Me.
“I was 21 when I started in this district and the confidence that I have developed and my whole personality have developed because of this school district, in a very positive way. I’m always smiling, I’m always happy. …
“The district has been so good to me all these years. I mean, oh my goodness. So good to me in more way than even I can explain.”
Jamie Rhine
7:31 am on Saturday, May 7, 2011
I love you Mrs. Leiderman! Thank you for giving the gift of education to our children thru love, compassion, consistancy and creativity. You have truly blessed my families life, and the foundation that you have provided for Jef will help him succeed not only developmentally but emotionally as well! Please teach preschool so the rest of my children can experience the same joy?!?!?
ruth leiderman
6:48 pm on Monday, May 9, 2011
Thanks, Jamie. I have so enjoyed being Jef's teacher this year. Promise me that we will always keep in touch!
Denise Wilkens
8:06 am on Saturday, May 7, 2011
Trentin and Kailey were both so fortunate to have you as their Kindergarten teacher. Because of you, I became a substitute teacher. Ruth, we love you and will miss you tremendously. You, my friend, really make a difference.
Taliah
8:20 am on Saturday, May 7, 2011
This is Taliah Hooker I was in her 2004-2005 kinder garden class I still have best friends from that class and I enjoyed being a late bird for class haha... love you mrs. Leiderman
ruth leiderman
6:50 pm on Monday, May 9, 2011
Hi, Taliah! Thanks for the nice comment. How did you get a hold of this article?
Miriam Raftery
9:47 am on Saturday, May 7, 2011
I went to Murray Manor back in the '60s. I had a wonderful kindergarten teacher named Mrs. Szymansky. It makes me sad to think of children being pushed to grow up too fast. I held our daughter back a year from starting school because the district had taken away naps and I saw how cranky she would be on days where she couldn't have a nap. Fostering creativity and a love of learning is so important! Where has all this "teaching to the test" taken us? I see teens who are stressed out and burned out. Let them be children--and thank goodness there are still teachers like Mrs. Leiderman.
ruth leiderman
6:51 pm on Monday, May 9, 2011
I am so glad that you agree with my philosophy. Maybe one day education will swing back as it once was.
Irith
9:43 am on Sunday, May 8, 2011
Mrs. Leidrman ( Ruthiet to me) is my sister. She never ceased to amaze me with her caring and dedication she showed towards her students. The district and the children she taught were indeed fortunate to have had her. I was also a teacher and in all my years in the field I have seen many excellent teachers but non who could hold a candle to her. She may retire but I don't believe that this is the end of Mrs. Leiderman's career in education
ruth leiderman
6:52 pm on Monday, May 9, 2011
Wrong...once I leave next year I am leaving education in its entirety!
Angela Large
10:50 pm on Sunday, May 8, 2011
Our daughter, Macayla Angela, had you, Mrs. Leiderman, in 2005, (wow 6 years ago)! Our family has grown to love, and respect you very much! Macayla, has learned patience, kindness, rules and steady work ethics from being in your class. Her first grade teacher said, she must have had an excellent Kindergarten teacher, Macayla, would start her homework for the next week, in class, to be ahead! Blake, was in the classroom with me when I volunteered in Macayla's Kindergarten class. Blake, couldn't wait to be in your class. Thank you for being ,"Our Blessed Teacher!" We're going to miss you very much! :}
ruth leiderman
6:53 pm on Monday, May 9, 2011
Thanks. You have always been so kind with your words. Makayla and Blake have been nothing but a joy in my class.
Heidi Bentz
11:27 am on Wednesday, July 6, 2011
Thank you, Mrs. Leiderman, for the message you are sending to Californians. Sometimes I feel like, "if the district is letting it happen, it can't be that bad", despite my heart breaking for my child. But when I see that a veteran kindy teacher like yourself just can't fathom appropriate classroom experiences happening for 5 year olds when the class sizes are so enormous and the curriculum is becoming so academic, it gives me hope that the tide can turn again. I chose Murray Manor for my son because I didn't want to rob him of his childhood in Kindergarten. I delighted in the play, the clay, the joy of Murray Manor's kindy. You and the other wonderful teachers at Murray Manor have fought to keep play in the classroom, and we are all beyond grateful. Thank you from my deepest heart. I wish you the very best in whatever your future brings you.